Papa Jimmy’s Pizzeria

Family-friendly pizzeria with made-from-scratch sauce and pizza dough

Papa Jimmy’s Pizzeria, also known as PJ’s Pizzeria, is a locally-owned and operated pizza place that is very active in the Cottage Grove community.

Their pizzas are made with the freshest ingredients, high-quality cheeses, and their very own pizza sauce recipe to give all of their pizzas a signature flavor.

Build your own pizza from their selection of toppings, or choose one of their specialty ones like Bellybuster loaded up with sausage, pepperoni, mushroom, onion, green pepper, and black olive, the Bucky Special with mushroom, sausage, cheddar, and mozzarella cheese, and much more!

In addition to pizzas, Papa Jimmy’s makes Italian pastas, calzones, and cold-cut subs. If there’s still room after dinner, get a dish of award-winning Chocolate Shoppe ice cream!

Delivery, carry out, or dine with them in the dining room or outside on the sunny patio beneath the pergola.

Rate and write a review

224 W Cottage Grove Rd
Cottage Grove WI 53527
Get directions

Main Menu:

View the Menu!
Regular Hours Mon - Thurs: 11am - 9pm Fri - Sat: 11am - 11pm Sun: 12pm - 9pm