Gotham Bagels

New York style bagels available in a tempting array of specialty flavors

Serving up the freshest New York style bagels this side of the Mississippi, Gotham Bagels are a homemade treat available plain or as the cap on one of their delicious sandwiches.

Come in for Gotham Bagels’ all-day breakfast with their bagels and fresh bread taking center stage. Choose from one of their almost 15 bagel flavors, and then pick one of their sandwich options like the egg, egg and cheddar, pastrami and egg, sausage, egg, and cheddar, or thick-cut bacon, egg, and cheddar.

If you’re feeling hungry, try one of their hot or cold signature sandwiches built with their bagels. Served with meats, cheese, vegetables, and spread.

Rate and write a review

112 E Mifflin St
Madison WI 53703
Get directions

Main Menu:

View the Menu!
Regular Hours Mon - Sat: 7am - 3pm Sun: 8am - 2pm